Dufault, Clarey win 4-Ball marathon

Karen Dufault and Carol Clarey outlast Roberta Hunt and Donna Warner in 26 holes in the title match of the OSWGA tourney.

01:00 AM EDT on Friday, August 20, 2004

BY PAUL KENYON
Journal Sports Writer

SWANSEA -- Last year, when Karen Dufault and Carol Clarey won their first Ocean State Women's Golf Association Four-Ball Championship, it was memorable for all the wrong reasons. Yesterday, when they won again, it was memorable for all the right reasons.

Clarey and Dufault pulled out one of the great matches that will be held by any state association this summer, outlasting Roberta Hunt and Donna Warner in 26 holes in the title match at Swansea Country Club.

The contest, the longest ever in an OSWGA event, was not decided until Dufault tapped in a short par putt on the eighth extra hole after each of the first seven had been halved with pars.

Both sides had several chances to win earlier. However, a number of birdie putts by each did not fall, while an even bigger number of clutch par-saving putts to keep the match going did. Clarey had the most dramatic of the saves, rolling in an uphill 15-footer on the 23rd to keep her team alive.

After two more halves, Dufault finally ended the marathon, nearly reaching the par-5 eighth in two. She putted from the fringe to five feet. Knowing she only needed a par to win, she rolled the birdie putt to the edge, then was conceded the par for the victory.

"That was a fabulous match," Clarey said in aptly summing up the show. "I would have enjoyed it sitting in a cart watching.

"I felt like we were both champions, that was so good," Dufault said. It was a stark contrast to last year, when one of their opponents, Brenda Nardolillo, could not play in the finals and Clarey and Dufault won, playing two-on-one against Marisa White.

This time, all four participants helped make it a special match. After spending nearly seven hours on the course, the players were drained over the final few holes.

"I thought it would come down to which side made the mistake first," Dufault said.

That is exactly what happened. Eventually.

On the 26th, Hunt, who played excellently in her return to competition -- she took time off to raise a family -- pushed her second shot into the trees. Warner hit her third shot, a chip from about 30 yards, heavy. The problems led to bogeys for both. Clarey also had tree problems and bogeyed.

For the longest time, it did not look as if either team would make a mistake. The sides were never more than one hole apart through all seven hours.

The match started wildly, with each side winning two of the first four holes. Each had a brief 1-up advantage before they were tied after five. From there, it was a demonstration on how many ways could be found to make par. Over the next 20 holes, 18 were halved -- all 18 with pars.

The contest stayed even from 5 through 12, where Dufault won with a par to put her team ahead. Dufault missed a chance to close out the match on the 17th, when her three-foot birdie putt to win the hole and the match spun all the way around the hole and stayed out.

Warner and Hunt stayed alive. But they needed to win 18. They did. Hunt hit a terrific 4-iron approach on the 361-yard hole to within 12 feet. But she never had to try the birdie putt. Dufault and Clarey both bogeyed. Warner then rolled in a 22-footer for her par to win the hole and send it to overtime.

Twice early in the extra session, Hunt was faced with par-saving putts of at least five feet to keep her team alive. And she made them. Later, it was Clarey who twice had to deal with par saves, knowing she needed them to keep her team alive, an eight-footer on the 21st and the 15-footer on the 23rd.

She made both of them, by which time all the players were getting a bit giddy. As they headed from green to tee, they were all laughing about how improbable this was.

"I need to go to the bathroom," Clarey said.

"I need something to eat. I'm drained," Warner said.

It kept going, with the players sometimes hitting the greens in regulation and missing birdie putts, other times getting up and down for pars. It was par after par after par until Dufault won it at the 26th.

It was a long day's work for all the finalists. In the first division, Kyong Kim and Annie Kim edged Kay Bullock and Denise Drainville in 20 holes. Mary Ann McLaughlin and Val Tessier merely went the regulation 18 to nip Judy Villani and Jannina McCloskey, 1 up.